Gigio’s Pizza Sebring

To the owner: I was hoping to find a great Florida pizza place and prove the stereotypes wrong. Instead, this felt disorganized and poorly managed. Inventory issues, inaccurate orders, no receipt, no delivery, and employees smoking at the entrance are not acceptable. Very disappointing experience. I’m from out of state and wanted to try a local pizza spot. Unfortunately, this was a mess from start to finish. Tried ordering online twice. Website says free delivery. Entered everything exactly how I wanted it, waited, and both times it failed after several minutes. I called instead. The employee acknowledged the online order coming through but said they don’t even have a delivery driver. Ordered three pizzas. Asked for garlic knots and cheese bread. Was told they didn’t make any that day

The best pizza in highlands county hands down! Great quality love the crust so crispy and thin the cheese was so stretchy and the sauce is perfect! The service is good, you have to have patience as there’s only one person handling everything, it’s worth the wait though because it’s the Best PIZZA!

Pizza crust is chewy yet crispy. Perfect! Tons of toppings! Garlic parm rolls so good! There were a few people there and I asked I'd it was good and they (owner), offered us a slice of their pizza! It is slower since they fresh make it right there but it is well worth it and they were beyond friendly. Will be back, for sure!!! BTW, price is really good for amount of food!

We’ve ordered twice now, and both times we were blown away by their delicious pizzas. The Margherita is the most traditional style we’ve found so far in Highlands and their gourmet Tuscany and New Orleans flatbreads are also so deliciously satisfying! We appreciate how they add just the right amount of cheese on their Neapolitana pies, the amazing sausage, fresh veggies and the generous amounts of great quality ingredients. This is now our new pizza place in Highlands, can’t wait to try more!

This is the second time that my order has been messed up. Today I ordered pizza, garlic knots, and chicken parmigiana. Apparently they are of of the chicken parm and did not have the decency to call me and just let the driver arrive and not know what was going on. The pizza bottom is burnt and the garlic knots are cold. I will never order from here again. When I called he showed no concern at all that I was upset