Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery

We highly recommend everything Gaetanos! From the salad, to the wings, to the calzone and pizza, everything we ordered was beyond fantastic! The prices are too low for the quality of food and service we experienced! 5 stars is not enough. They earned and deserve much more!

Jenks Gaetano’s is truly a hidden gem for those in Bixby . We don’t have to battle traffic on Memorial Rd and their pizza is spot on every time. The pizza rolls as an appetizer also comes in clutch.

The best part of the menu was the dessert. Some of the meals we received seemed to be microwaved while others seemed fresh. The dry pasta was served at the same time as the one with sauce. Appetizers came after the meal, and some of our group waited 45+ for appetizers. Server was super sweet but the food just seemed be reheated and not homemade.

We love this place!! They are so accommodating and the pizza and pasta and subs are amazing, and the ice cream is also fantastic! Every time we’ve stopped in it’s been great service, even when we bring in large parties.

This was our first time eating here, and most likely be a one time. The Alfredo sauce was the only good thing. The dough for the calzone and the pizza was pretty raw. I mean it was still completely stretchy. The chicken for the Alfredo was grayish in color and very rubbery. The fried ravioli tasted the exact same as the great value brand ones in the freezer section of Walmart.