Fat Boy's Pizza

I placed an order for a sheet pizza a few days earlier. I came to pick it up on that Saturday about 10 minutes after the scheduled time. The pizza was burnt when initially cooked but when I picked it up it was cold. I also ordered a salad, and on top of the tray cover it had the date written ontop, which means it wasn’t prepared the same day. (Scheduled time was later in afternoon) So who knows how long the salad was sitting there, but I will say all ingredients seemed ok, nothing looked wilted or rotten. Either way it was very disappointing to pay for such a large pizza that came out looking the way it did, ontop of being cold. I got a burnt cold pizza, with extra large crust?? Could have at least gave me enough cheese…..

We loved Fat Boys until a couple of weeks ago. I wasn’t going to leave a bad review, but it’s been bothering me. We ordered an 8 piece chicken dinner with sides. The chicken was sub-standard, dried out and you could not tell a leg from a breast! The coleslaw was off, tasted bad.. We were afraid to eat it. We ate what we could and tossed the rest. The next day my husband called to let them know how bad it was, he was polite and explained how we have been ordering there for last 25 years. The manager was not sympathetic and told us we could bring back the 2 pieces we didn’t eat and they would exchange them or they could give us 20% off next time. We decided there won’t be a next time. I guess customer loyalty doesn’t mean much anymore.

I ordered a small pepperoni pizza that was extremely greasy. The whole bottom of the cardboard box was covered in grease. I ordered mozzarella sticks. They absolutely had no kind of seasoning or flavor. It was literally fried cheese and I also ordered garlic bread. This place has the audacity to give you a hotdog bun smothered in butter that only smells like garlic no taste of garlic at all. I definitely would not recommend this place. I will never go back. What a waste of money.

This place is my jam. I love everything they have here. My go-to has been the wings forever. Always gotta get some mushrooms, too. My son loves the chicken and jojos. We even had them cater our baby shower before. Everyone loved it. My brother has me bring them down (the wings) every time I visit Westerville. I love it when my four year old says, *Papa, can we get Fat Boys tonight?* Only gripe. My driveway is 8 minutes from your lot. It doesn't make sense that you don't deliver to me. I used to order a lot more frequently when you delivered to me. However, my wallet and waistline thank you.

The wife I stopped in to grab something to eat. And we had never been there before. The food was very good. And the service was great.