Cugini's Pizza Middletown, NJ

Today I ordered a whole pie, (Grandma's pie) when I got back to my shop 7 minutes down the road, I opened the box to see a burnt and cold pizza. I was no less than 10 minutes late to pick up the pie, but it seems like my pizza wasn't fresh. It was tasty and edible but I was overall disappointed with the pizza. Every bite was crunch, crunch, crunch. 😞 From now on, I will always check my pizza before I leave. P.s. it was even worse after re-heating it, barely edible. Downgraded my review from 2 star to 1 star. Worst Grandma's pie i have ever eaten.

Me and my mom came here on break really good slices of pizza. I got two plain. She got two buffalo chicken service was great. Customer service is great think all together came to 16 bucks not bad. Pizza was delicious we will be back soon ! Make this your next spot to eat !

I ordered a small arugula salad along with the rest of my family’s order. When order arrived (via takeout) and I saw that I was charged $14.99 for this tiny salad, I called to speak with someone because I was certain they made a mistake and overcharged thinking I ordered a large. The young person who I spoke with at first was completely RUDE, insisted that the small salad is in fact $14.99, and couldn’t understand why I was calling to talk this out. The owner heard him speaking with me and quickly got in the phone asking what was up. I explained it to him…and even he didn’t understand how absurd charging $14.99 for a small salad is. A salad this size wouldn’t even be $14.99 at JFK airport, let alone Middletown NJ. Oh, and by the way, the large costs $17.99 - how does this make sense? See p

Pizza joints are one and 1 million especially in New Jersey but once in a while you find one that truly takes your breath away! And I think I found it.. From the upside down, Sicilians to the inventive rolls , the owner comes up with this place is just phenomenal! The Napoleon dynamite slice is crazy, pizza rolls, buffalo chicken rolls everything you can think of! I can’t wait to come back for dinner. Try the rest of the menu.

I’ve been to Cugini’s many times and the food is always solid and definitely one of the better pizzerias in Middletown. This time we ordered a Chicken Vodka panini, French fries, a Texas Burger, a Grandma pie, a Chicken & Spinach Alfredo pie, and a Margherita with toppings. Ordered online at 5:20 p.m. for a 6:00 pickup, but when we arrived, the place was packed with at least 15 people waiting for pick up and my order wasn’t close to being completed. My order wasn’t ready until 6:35 p.m. The biggest issue is the pickup system. They don’t ask for names or give out order numbers, so orders get mixed up constantly. When you go in, they ask you what items you ordered and try and piece your order together. I even saw a customer waiting 20 minutes for a personal pizza, only to be handed a large h