Colony Grill

5/5 Stars - A Legendary Pie! This Place Fully Lives Up to the Hype. Colony Grill is an absolute institution, and after just one visit, it's easy to see why. This isn't just another pizza joint; it's a masterclass in perfecting one thing and doing it exceptionally well. The atmosphere is exactly what you want it to be: lively, casual, and unpretentious. It's the perfect spot to grab a booth with friends, catch a game on the TVs, and enjoy a cold drink from the bar. The energy is always great. Now, the main event: THE PIZZA. The thin crust is a thing of beauty—incredibly crisp, cracker-like, and with those delightfully charred, airy edges. But the real game-changer is the signature hot oil. Don't let the name intimidate you; it's not just heat, it's packed with flavor and adds a phenomena

A legendary spot for hot oil pizza—and it delivers. The crust is thin, the kick is real, and the vibe is buzzy and classic. That said, I have to admit: Riko’s Pizza in Stamford (started by former Colony staff) edges them out. Riko’s is thinner, crispier, and has just a bit more flavor punch. Still, Colony is worth the visit for the history and great energy.

Amazing thin crust pizza in true new york fashion. Located in Port Chester and Stamford. The Port Chester outlet is pretty massive (used to be a hardware store), with a big parking lot, and very rustic, cosy vibes as per how a nice old school cocktail bar should look and feel like. Pizza servings are enormously huge - about 6-8 slices per personal pan. You select your own toppings on top of the pizza at $1.95 each topping. Amazing service too and really loved the pizza. Well done, fresh ingredients and crusts were toasted to perfection. Absolutely love a try if you are around the area. Prices are super reasonable for its portion and quality. Also a really cool spot to just relax and enjoy a game of football over a nice cold beer at the counter bar. Large parking space available outside.

Very good bar pizza, thin crust is very well executed.

Excellent example of Ct oil pizza. Not for everyone but I find very tasty. Also the added advantage of being open later than most places to eat in lower Westchester. Feel Is total bar food. Large place and easy to slide in to late night quick and affordable. Also a fai number of bears on tap.