Celestino's Pizza & Ristorante (Cedar Grove)

I tried Celestino's and I’m officially hooked. I ordered the spinach Philly cheesesteak wrap and it was SO good. I asked for mayo on the side, but honestly… I didn’t even need it. The wrap was already packed with flavor and perfectly seasoned. Everything tasted fresh and balanced. On top of that, the staff is super cool and genuinely kind, great energy all around. Definitely found my new go-to spot for wraps :) Shoutout to Jessie, the guy who took my order great energy and super helpful.

Ordered a 'lightly cooked' Grandma pizza (since it is still the same as when it was Espositos) for the 3rd or 4th time under Celestinos. The guy taking the order over the phone even repeated the 'lightly cooked' part. Was craving the pizza... unfortunately it was well done...big disappointment. For what it's worth, the older guy that cooked the pizza the other times was not there and this review is based solely on today's pizza experience. If the pizza did not cost $25, I probably would not be writing this review...will not be ordering again for a while.

Just ordered lunch for my family and some workers we have at the house. Everyone agrees the food is great, the level of service the gentleman behind the counter gave me is superb and this is a constant. Service and food are always 100% Thank you for always being on your game

Last night, I arrived just moments before closing, uncertain if I’d still be able to order. To my pleasant surprise, the staff warmly welcomed me, assured me it was no trouble at all, and graciously accepted my order. Despite being ready to end their shift, they prepared my meal with genuine care and cheerful professionalism. Every team member I encountered greeted me courteously and went above and beyond to make the experience enjoyable. Truly exceptional service—10/10 in every respect.”

Ordered takeout for a birthday party and everything was delicious! We tried the penne vodka, the calamari and their cheese pies. Everything was delicious and their attention to details is awesome. Sent in all the sides and sauces without us even mentioning it. On time delivery and very courteous staff. Can’t wait to try other menu items soon!! Thank you. We will be back.