Carlo’s Pizza of Port Washington

I ordered chicken parmigiana with extra sauce at the counter. The menu painted on the board over the counter was extensive but no prices were provided. I waited about 15 minutes for table service. The meal was served on a porcelain plate with metal utensils. The spaghetti was wet with sauce with extra on top and was cooked a bit beyond al dente, with a plastic container of sauce on the side. A 6” section of hot Italian bread,sliced every 1/2 inch, with two large, hard patties of butter was wrapped in paper on the side. The chicken fillet was in pieces, some small and some larger, about 1/4-3/8 inch thick. The smaller pieces were soft and tasty. The larger pieces were hard and required the knife. The sauce was tasty and appeared to be restaurant prepared. The cost of the meal was $23.44 inc

The food and the staff are consistently excellent. I’m especially a fan of their plain and white pizzas, also their eggplant parm, which help make this easily the best spot in town. If you’re visiting or trying to decide where to eat, don’t pass this place up. We’ve been eating here for more than 10 years, and it has never disappointed. The pizza is always incredible.

Incredible First Experience Tried for the first time, and I was blown away! The pizza was absolutely amazing—perfectly balanced with a flavorful sauce, just the right amount of cheese, and cooked to perfection with a deliciously crisp crust. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, even surprising me with two complimentary slices! That kind of generosity and customer service goes a long way. Overall, a fantastic first visit—I’ll definitely be coming back for more! Highly recommend giving them a try if you haven’t already!

Great stop for pizza. The dough is very well made. One of the better tasting pies I've ever tried. Street parking available. Prices are decent with many food options if pizza isn't your thing. The seating area is smaller so if you have more than 4 people in your party, you'll have to take more than 1 table.

Best Pizza Place in town , and also in my humble opinion; the best pizza place in New York. I’ve been coming here since I was three years old with my parents and ever since then been eating here since almost 3 decades of my life. I love this pizzeria and their pizza 🍕.