Black Sheep Bagels Cutchogue

Delicious bagels!!!! We had the asiago and cheddar jalapeño and both were delicious. They don't skimp on the cheese on top! Asiago almost tasted like grilled cheese!

Best bagels on the North Fork. Fresh warm and cooked to perfection in house. The flavored cream cheese are excellent. All the sandwiches are really good too. They never disappoint!

Great spot for yummy bagels and such. Everything u need for breakfast! The quiche is no crust 😊. There are tables outside if u want to sit.

Second time having Black Sheep Bagels and both times was very impressed. The iced coffee is served with coffee iced cubes! Won’t get watered down, I love it! The bagels are also great! Definitely give it a try! Also the have bagel cannolis! They’re pretty good

Continuing on our search for the best NY style bagel on the North Fork brought us to Black Sheep Bagels. Somewhere out there I think what is the right NY style bagel had changed since one review said this bagel store had the quintessential NY bagel that was soft and pillowy. I like mine with a nice crisp crust and even dense crumb. While the bagels were good they are not fundamentally NY style bagels as I described. They were soft and pillowy. So good but not great. Would go again but I think a sandwich would be better than a plain bagel or one with cream cheese. Very bready bagels.