Athenian Shish Kebob

My in-laws have been eating here for decades. This restaurant is a neighborhood institution. The food is always good and the portions are big. We almost always have leftovers to take home. My favorites are the Greek salad and the chicken shish kebab. Oh and the baklava is the best!

Aquí tienes la traducción al inglés del review: We went to eat and there were only three tables, but the waitress Lexie was in a hurry for us to leave. She brought the check without us asking and asked if I wanted a box while I was still eating. The food was very bland, and by mistake, we left a $50 tip — the cashier didn’t say anything. Luckily, we realized it because the bill was under $50, so it was clearly a mistake. We also ordered a pie for dessert, and the waitress said they didn’t have any and told us to get it from the place next door — what??? I don’t understand why this place has such good reviews. It’s not worth it.

I'm Italian. I can't speak to the ethnic authenticity of the food served at Athenian, but I know good food and this place has consistently great food and service. Helpful and friendly staff. Always busy, but rarely a wait for a booth. Reminds me of the diners I grew up with in NJ. Laid back, simple, good food. Nothing fancy or pretentious. My wife and I often stop here when we are out shopping and want something quick and tasty and reasonably priced. Food fast, not fast food. Our quick go-to is bowls of Lemon Rice soup, and shared Sag anaki. OPA! If we are looking for something more substantial we will often order their Pasta Athenia. Spaghetti tossed with Feta and chunks of grilled chicken. Delicious and generous enough for sharing, or for taking home leftovers.

Absolutely love this place for a solid traditional Greek meal! My go to is the chicken kebab, Greek salad, moussaka, and spinach pie . This place is always fast and friendly and clean. If you’re looking for a quick home cooked meal on the go, this place cannot be beat.

Very friendly staff. Food cooked to order; and always good. Always served hot as soon as prepared (doesn't sit unattended under a warming light). Breakfast is pretty generic but Greek variations are available. Food fairly priced. Waitstaff is very responsive.