Anthony's Pizza

Not a bad place, shopping center is holding it back, if they can get a few well lit stores in that corner it would provide a better environment for good business. The pizza is nice and thin giving the pizza a nice cook. Toppings are fresh and their smaller sized pizza is not bad for 2. There's a whole Italian food menu, not just pizza and you can dine in where I've seen them have live performances. Feels a bit more premium without the bloatiness you get after eating other pizzas.

Was a wonderful spot to hit after walking through the caverns. My two kids were starving--service was fast, food was filling and delicious. My daughter is a pasta snob but loved the sauce here. My son devoured the wings and pizza. Was a great meal, great price and our server was very good.

I was a very frequent customer of Anthony's, the owner knows that, he's the one that made it known that I was when I had ordered a 2 liter months back & didn't get it with my order. So, I called to let them know & the owner said "you order from us a lot so next time call and order and let me know I owe you a 2 liter & I'll get it to you then". Well, that all changed today. Myself, my husband and my daughter ordered Anthony's last night (2/13/26) for delivery, it was late I'll admit that, around 9:00PM (they're open for delivery until 10:15 PM & close at 11:00 PM). We had lost track of time doing home renovations & were starving since we hadn't had time to eat anything. We were super excited we were still in the timeframe to order from Anthony's for delivery. A simple order, two 6" hoagies

There seems to be a lot of conflicting reviews for this place, but I still decided to give a try as I planned to before I arrived. The online order was easy to use and it said the order would be done in about 20-30. Took me about 20 mins to get there and the food was ready, no issues with that. I ordered a chicken calzone, small sicilian pizza, mozzarella sticks(6 total), and bacon cheese fries. The calzone was phenomenal and it was by far the best part of the meal. The pizza was insanely mid…crust was way too tough and it felt like it was grocery store bought. The moz sticks were very similar as well, nothing too extraordinary but got the job done. The bacon cheese fries tasted like the cheese was a cheese sauce on nachos, not the melted shredded cheese we had expected.

Our delivery was taken to the wrong address and left on a neighbors porch that we had to drive to get. The calzone was virtually just bread with one piece of ham, and it was burnt. The pizza was missing three toppings that cost an extra ten dollars. When we called the store to talk to the manager about the issue, the manager wouldn't answer the phone, and we were told to report it to the online order app for a refund for the toppings. We spent over $100 for the items in the pictures plus a 20% tip for the delivery. The food and service were both abysmal. My sister lives locally and is currently posting to everyone on Facebook. She is getting feedback from locals that this is NOT the place to go. Please do not waste your time or money on this place.