Alimentari Beach Montauk

The pasta was spot on…we got the ragu and the lasagna, and the portions were generous, and the flavor was on point and needed no additions. The appetizer of the artichokes were perfectly fried and the sauce it came with was a good compliment. My peach spritz was delicious and my husband’s margarita with fresh cantaloupe juice was unique and went down easy. We would definitely come here again.

Incredible and engaging staff. Wonderful food. So accommodating and kind. Very relaxed and fun atmosphere. Not your typical Italian food but so exciting and delicious. Thank you so much. The pork sandwich was an absolute stand out as our waitress told us. Incredible house made bread.

This is better than any NYC Italian spot I’ve ever been to. We got the Tartufo pizza, Nonis lasagna, cascatelli ragu, calamari, and tiramisu. The cascatelli and calamari are insanely good, textures on point! Please support this amazing gem 😋

Our dinner at Alimentari was a true delight. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with large windows that give the space an airy, spacious feel. The service is friendly and attentive, making for a truly relaxing dining experience. Loved the fresh cocktails, the Italian wedge salad and Neapolitan-style pizza topped with burrata that had a wonderfully light and crispy crust. It's a fantastic spot that brings a genuine taste of Italian coastal dining to the heart of Montauk.

Came in for brunch on a Saturday afternoon in July. This place is right in the heart of downtown Montauk, very good location, nice seating and good air conditioning. Nice wide windows with a view of the town. Coffee was superb, and so was the food. I had the breakfast sandwich which was very gourmet and delicious. My wife had the New Yorker personal pizza and it was great. My brother had the Calabrese and loved it. Will be back!