Bennett Shellfish

We had the best lobster roll and experience at Bennett’s that we had to go back again in the same week! This time we ordered the lobster rolls and tried the lobster bisque as well and oh my goodness it was delicious and we’re so glad we did! Everything we ordered the main ingredient is actually fresh lobster, and they don’t hold back on the amount and you can’t beat the price! The owners are so beyond kind and the place is so cute and clean. You definitely have repeat customers for life! A true Montauk gem and staple.

I ordered their lobster pizza. Which is first come first serve. Because they sell out pretty quick and sometimes they don't have it for days. But I was resilient and kept in touch with the owners and made sure to set aside one for me. These aren't mass produced. A local baker makes the crust and delivers the crust etc and the owners add the mostly lobster claws to it the vacuum seal and freeze it. Most their food you have to bring home and eat it. They have smoked fish dip which was good and lobster rolls they make ready to eat. two lobster rolls for 38 dollars and a bag of chips is the best deal out there. The fish dip is good as well as the dessert they offer I got key lime and some type of mousse cake I'm waiting to heat up the lobster money pizza thing. I gave it 4 stars because its c

Visited Montauk for the first time with friends who are regulars here, and I can see why this is their must-stop spot. The oysters were incredibly fresh and delicious—especially with the cocktail sauce and jalapeño candy (OMG, so good!). The lobster rolls were excellent, and my friends picked up a variety of fish to bring back to Brooklyn. The owners were warm and welcoming, and the shop itself is so charming. Truly a Montauk gem!

PHENOMENAL!!!! Wow wow wow! This was our first stop on our weekend in Montauk and it was the best deal we found the whole trip! Absolutely delicious fresh lobster and a STEAL at 2 for $35! Be prepared as it is cash only, as are quite a few establishments in town. 2 PACKED lobster rolls WITH 2 bags of chips for less than what all the other businesses around charge for ONE roll with no sides or extras! Amazing! We were welcomed lovingly by the owner and felt like we were visiting an old friend! It was the perfect first stop as we were exhausted from driving and wanted to have some good food and turn in for the night. It would be a crime to visit Montauk and not stop here. Multiple times. In fact, I’m on my way back before we leave! 10/10 recommend!

Took a day trip to Montauk with my mom and my aunts to explore the area for the first time, and of course, lobster rolls were on the list. This seafood shop popped up at the top of Google Maps, so we decided to stop by and grab a bite. We were greeted by a very kind and welcoming lady at the counter. We ordered four lobster rolls (2 for 1 deal!) and the total came out to $78. This was a great deal and so worth it since you can't beat this price in the city!! The lobster was fresh and definitely hit the spot. Would've enjoyed it even more if the roll was toasted. But, overall we were all satisfied and would stop by again to try other items on their menu. Also, just a heads up - it’s cash only! ☺️