Alicea's NY Bagels & Subs Llc

Driven past so many times saying I need to stop in and give them a try. Well I finally stopped and wasn't disappointed. Went with a simple turkey and provolone sub. For such a simple sandwich it was really good. Comes with the usual garnish plus banana peppers and pickles. The seasoning and dressing they put on really made the sandwich. I also picked up a couple bagels for future breakfasts. Tried the poppy seed bagel this morning and was happy I got it. Way better than Einstein bagels and about as close to a NY bagel I could find in this city. Can't wait to go back and try one of their signature sandwiches.

Good flavor , I got the New Yorker and added roast beef. But I want my other 4 inches of sandwich comped or it’ll stay a 3 star review .tape measure for literal scale. You charge $17 for a 14 inch and I was expecting what I paid for . A little disappointing , otherwise it was solid . I also got an everything bagel that was great . $25 out the door , if they do right and get me my other piece of sandwich I was shorted I’ll go back .

I went in about a week ago and I was (am) homeless (still am but might have a place very soon) and this nice woman who I believe if I remember correctly name was Jessica was working at the time. I walked in not looking my best (let's just say) and she greeted me very kindly and did not look at me like a piece of trash like most of the other people in the area whom also have their heads up their butts mainly do. I told her I was hungry but didn't really have any money at that time. I was embarrassed asking but I asked her if she had any food that the company was throwing out. She said no but I will make you a bagel and proceeded to ask me what I wanted on it. I thought to myself wow this is incredibly hospitable and was very thankful as I was really hungry. She came out a few minutes later

First time trying this place. We ordered 5 sandwiches, all were decent except the Reuben. Definitely did NOT look like the photo (photo shows lots of meat) there was hardly any sauerkraut and the thousand island dressing was very sweet. Not worth $16. Menu also advertises kettle chips with all sandwiches. They were wavy lays or something similar. Not kettle chips. A little disappointing. I appreciate the fact that it smelled clean, but the cleaner they use was very overpowering.

This is a minimalist's dream! A small rack holding 6-8 different types of bagels, a cash counter and couple minimally stocked refrigerators for drinks. The bagels are fresh and doughy, for this they deserve a 5! We ordered a Reuben to split. I don't know if what I got could really be called a Reuben, it was toasted not grilled, so the meat and cheese inside were cold, the meat was thick sliced instead of shaved. For this I give them a 3. I'm sure their subs are better, but I haven't tried them.