Wantagh Inn

Went recently for a friend’s birthday party and the staff were very nice and accommodating. The food was really good. Would highly recommend the everything pretzel and the sliced London broil sandwich!

On New Year's Day... I had made early dinner reservations at the Wantagh Inn for myself and my two friends. I had never been there and I had always heard good reviews. It was Thursday and it was also steak night for $30. It was a choice of flat iron, skirt or sirloin steak with mashed and veggies. We started with the fried calamari and chicken quesadillas as appetizers. They were really good. All three of us had the mistletoe margaritas. They were delicious and served in mason jars. We all ordered the flat iron after we asked our server Kay for a recommendation. She was also great and very attentive. The food was delicious, steak cooked to perfection. I asked for a side of gravy that was also delish. For dessert we shared a warm brownie with vanilla ice cream and fresh whipped cream. I lov

This place is a classic Irish pub. Big menu with lots of specialties. Updated prices with the full menu in my pictures.

Abysmal parking situation. Very nice main dining room for family gatherings. I attended a baby shower upstairs. Only one server working entire party, so patience was needed! Very weird bathroom placement; right behind hostess station. Only two stalls for entire restaurant. Not at all wheelchair friendly. Salmon made my stomach a bit queasy for remainder of day.

Went there for dinner with another couple. Reservations were definitely needed and we were seated right away. The place was packed and very loud. Service was not the best but I don't know if that was do to the place being so crowded. The food was excellent but again it was so loud that it was difficult to carry on any conversation. I would still recommend it.