Connemara Baking Co.

So I went here after getting off the train once. I live in wantagh, grew up in wantagh. Had to check it out. Holy cow. I have to say.. I’ve never left a Google review in my life. It took me some time to figure out. I have a sweet tooth for sure and I need to come on here and say I had the best cupcake ive ever had in my life here. I still talk about this cupcake a year later. I dream of this cupcake. It was A basic vanilla with choc frosting. It was PERFECT. Like truly she has perfected her treats. Which is why I think she’s open one day and puts all her love and expertise into her one day of goodies. I hate over complicated bakery items , You know like the over the top ones with all the toppings and such. I’m trying to explain what I mean but- you just need to go in and try. The flavor ha

Today I placed an order for cupcakes for my daughter in law’s baby shower, and I also bought a few of the cupcakes and other bakery items home to sample. Everything was delicious! I recommend Connemara Bakery company to anyone looking for something special, and delicious, and u can tell everything is made from the love of baking. Also the owner and the staff are very pleasant, they greet you with a warm hello, and bid u a nice day when u leave.

So excited to have found this charming bakery so close to home. I pre ordered the lemon cake for New Year's and it is definitely one of the best I've had. So light and flavorful. Also tried the vanilla cupcakes as well as the coconut ones and the Amish cookies. Everyone was thrilled and we definitely found our new local bakery. The owner is lovely and the complimentary coffee and tea offering while you're there is a nice touch. Wishing this new bakery the very best of luck!

The most wonderful bakery on Long Island! It seems like every week brings a delicious new special, which needs to be paired with the amazing regular offerings they have. The banana pudding is bananas delicious! Love this place and the owners are the nicest people ever!!

Absolutely delicious and stunning. You will not be disappointed. Quality ingredients baked with knowledge and love.recent visit we had the amissh sugar cookies nice and light cupcakes moist and firm and yes the carrot cake anything is to die for. Well worth the vist if your looking for snacks above the normal run of the mill and the store is unbelievably clean and charming