Vinny's Italian Kitchen

As a partition lawyer, I spend most days dealing with stressful property disputes and court deadlines — so when I get a break, I appreciate places that are consistently excellent. Vinny Italian Market never disappoints. The food is outstanding, the ingredients are fresh, and the sandwiches are as legit as it gets. The staff is friendly, efficient, and treats everyone like a regular, whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth. It’s the kind of place you stop by for lunch and end up bringing something home for dinner. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian market with great food, fair prices, and real neighborhood vibes, Vinny’s is the place. Highly recommended — and a well-earned go-to after a long day at the office

Great place. Amazing food selection!!! You won't want to miss this gem on AMI. Check the menu out on the QR code. Can't wait to try some of the pasta dinners!!!! ENJOY!!!!🇮🇹💯🔥

So we just stopped in for a pizza! OMG! It was amazing! Probably one of the best we have EVER had! The lady at the counter was so friendly, the place made me feel like I was in Italy. Vinnie, you should be very proud of the fact that you made our day on AMI!

Vinny’s is a must stop for us when staying on AMI! We grabbed a take & bake pan of lasagna, loaf of bread and some pickled veggies. Nice Sunday dinner at our resort without spending a ton of money!

First time coming to Vinnys. We live just off the island. Service is extremely slow. Tables outside were dirty and it was at opening time. Pizza was horrible. No flavor and the crust was wet. We each had one slice and threw the rest out. Very disappointing! If he took time to clean up inside and organize better, he could have a few inside tables.