Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff

My friend and I stopped by Holy Cow last week. As a Celiac I was fully prepared to get a boring cup of ice cream, I was so surprised they had both gluten free cake and sugar cones! The owner told me it breaks his heart when kids come in and they can’t get a cone like the rest of the family. The owners are so sweet and the ice cream is delicious!

Phenomenal ice cream and excellent service! All of the employees were accommodating and friendly. We travel a lot and always love going to small town places to try their homemade ice creams. This is by far my favorite that I’ve ever had! It took a while to decide on a flavor. I nearly had to try them all. Each flavor I sampled was more delicious than the next! I finally decided on the brownie batter and peanut butter trash can. Also pictured is the blueberry cobbler.

Extremely friendly, family-oriented ice cream joint! We thoroughly enjoyed the attention, the laughs, and the great service that we received. Hand-dipped ice cream, with plenty of options for everyone. They have some off the wall options as well. Great treat for after dinner, or after a full day at the beach, or maybe just on a rainy day like we did.

Absolutely loved everything about this place! They make their own hard ice cream in a facility off-island, and it is delicious. The owner was lovely to chat with and very friendly. Our condo rental was across the street and one of the best perks was having this place so close by. Sundaes are great, too, but this ice cream is perfect all by itself. This is a must-visit place if you are in the area.

BEST ICE CREAM ON THE ISLAND!!!! Staff is so sweet and they even offered to take my picture. This is a must when visiting AMI!!