Villa Roma Pizza & Subs

Decent pizza. We got the white pizza and it comes with tomato, broccoli, cheese and ricotta. The toppings were nice and fresh. It said it had some type of garlic sauce on it, but I didn’t taste any at all. The crust is a little too crispy for our liking - it’s like you’re trying to rip leather once you get to the crust. Overall, it was okay just a little bland. Also a little pricey for just pizza.

Fantastic customer service, great location, long standing reputation, & the food is the best part. No wonder this place has been opened for 60+ years. I definitely recommend!

What a great find while out and about in the little shops around here! The pizza was delicious and a must order. We did a meat pizza and got to watch the dough getting stretched and prepped. Usually meat pizza is very greasy but this one was not. The crust was super crispy on the bottom and a 10/10 for us. We also got a drink, 12 honey bbq wings, and mozzarella sticks in addition to the medium meat pizza for $50. The wings were good but I'd get them extra crispy next time. Skip the ranch, it wasn't that good buttermilk ranch and tasted like your average bottled ranch. The mozzarella sticks were good but pricey at $8 for five. We would definitely come back, just for pizza. The subs looked huge and the bread looked so fresh, so maybe we will try that next time too!

Villa Roma has been my pizza place of choice ever since I was a little kid. The food is fantastic, the workers always friendly and attentive. It's been great to see how well they've been doing over the ueats and I'll continue to eat here for as long as I'm in New Cumberland!

Edit unsure how to reply to the owners reply so I’ll add it here, this was our first time ordering from here so unfortunately I did not have a menu nor know what the menu says as when I asked for one when I got there I was told they didn’t have menus yet for the pizza shop but gave me one for a taco shop around the corner. And every Italian Stromboli I’ve ever ordered had pepperoni on it not just ham… so if I’d known it was just ham i probably wouldn’t had ordered that. Ordered a Italian Stromboli and there was only ham and a few small pieces of salami that was chopped up no pepperoni at all very disappointing as I really wanted it we also ordered a small cheese pizza which tasted off also for over 40 bucks I expected better.