Uncle Matty's Eatery

Uncle Matty's Eatery has the best food, drinks, service, and atmosphere. Everything is fresh and made to order. The burgers and wings are amazing! I also love the pasta, entrees, and weekend specials. The beer and wine selection is unique and delicious! Dj makes fantastic drinks. Krista is super friendly and accommodating. The twins are very sweet and provide great service! The kitchen staff is always hustling and cooking our meals to perfection! Uncle Matty's is super clean and it is evident the owner and staff care. Definitely recommend this established... it is a hidden gem is not only New Windsor, but Carroll County!

I don't really leave bad reviews on places, especially locally owned establishments, but our recent experience here certainly warrants one. We got take out and ordered 2 cheesesteak subs, boom boom shrimp, and crab dip. The shrimp had a great flavor but they were very tough and chewy. Crab dip was ice cold and had the consistency of paste. That was not the biggest issue though. The one cheesesteak had a plastic bread tie in it that we noticed after pulling one half of the sandwich out of the box. We tried calling, but they had already closed so we contacted the manager the next day and we were given explanations about how they serve their food and then they requested us to send them a picture of the sub. We promptly sent the picture of the sub and a little while later the manager messaged

My son and I stepped in for an early and were pleasantly surprised we had the barbecue chicken and the Matty Melt along with a cup of crab soup each. Service was great and the food was excellent. Will be sure to stop in next time we’re in the area.

Update: 2 stars. Far too inconsistent. Sometimes it is a 5* sometimes, like tonight it is 1* (if that). Have ordered a burger Medium Rare at least 6-8 times. Maybe half the time they get it right. The other half of the time it isn't even close, very well done, all grey, dry, not good. This trip was an all-around train wreck. Arrived to a basically empty dining room at 5:45. Only 2 tables seated ahead of us. Appetizers took 30 mins. Meals were 45 mins. Delivered some of our food and the rest didn't arrive for nearly 10 mins. Entrees with no sides for 10 mins. Ordered 2 burgers Medium Rare, both came out very well done. This happens far too often here. Try to give them the benefit of the doubt but far too inconsistent. Never were checked on to ask of everything was alright. The servers are g

The first time being here. I had the Cheese Burger with a side of homemade potato chips and a pickle slice. The burger was cooked perfectly and the flavor was fantastic. I came for lunch so it wasn't busy but the service was fast and the atmosphere was pleasant. My only complaint is that the plate was too small for all this food. The burger was enormous and messy but that's what makes it so good. I'll definitely be coming back.