Totowa Pizza

Soooooo.... Disappointed and dissatisfied tonight. I ordered what I thought would be a Sicilian Square pie. Well, my search still continues to find an authentic Sicilian pizza. This so-called Sicilian pizza was watery, somewhat greasy, and nowhere near the crispy airy 1-1/2" thick True Sicilian. Put it this way I was able to eat 7 slices. I've tried about 6 different pizzerias, and still nothing. I've had their eggplant sandwich and hot mussels, and I must say the sauce was pretty good. Also, the quantity and freshness were there.

Pizza is amazing!! Highly recommend to try thin crust. And Cesar Salad with grilled chicken

I’m a High School student and come here every Friday that I can. The food here is both affordable and delicious with a horizon of choices beyond just pizza (the pizza is pretty amazing too). My favorites include the “How You Doin” burger, “Big Delizia Hero” Hot Sub (my favorite), the “White w/ Broccoli” pizza, and the Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad (pictured below).

Worst service ever from owner at Totowa Pizza. Ordered a pie, and food had not been delivered in over an hour. Called just to see how much longer food would take and was told seven minutes. Another 20 mins have passed before calling again just to cancel the order as I did not want to eat cold pizza. Woman on the phone transferred phone over manager who explained that she will cancel the order no problem but to not call their again to place orders. I mentioned that a customer does not want to eat cold pizza, she mentioned that wasn’t her concern and she will cancel the order . She repeated don’t order here again and hung up. Extremely horrible way to run a business .

There are a lot of pizzerias in the area and I find this one to be the best out of all of them.