The Sweet and Savory Pie Company Petoskey

A wonderful place to pick up the perfect sweet item for your evening or event. There is a comfortable atmosphere and a wide variety of pies to choose from. These pies are a centerpiece dessert item. They are memorably good- if you bring one of these to an event, people are going to remember how good it was. I wasn’t fully prepared for just how hefty, thick, crisp, and delicious the Apple Caramel Crumble was going to be. And it was absolutely spot on perfect- the Apple was crisp, the caramel was thick and sweet. You can tell these people are pro’s because they managed to hit every aspect of this pie spot on.The pie was thick but everything was cooked evenly and not under or overdone. The flavors were vibrant but not overpowering. The overall pie was sweet without being “too sweet”. You c

Our partner and I stopped by this place on a roadtrip through northern Michigan - it was too cute from the street to pass by. We have ZERO regrets. We got slices of the Cherry and Peach, and individual sized Butter Chicken and Steak and Guinness. I can’t emphasize enough how wonderful they all were. The savory pies particularly blew us away. The crust was flaky and buttery and melt in your mouth. The butter chicken was particularly amazing, the flavors were very warm and rich. If you’re ever in the area, do yourself the favor of just stopping in. Even if you don’t purchase anything, you’ll still have a nice escape into some fun ambiance, fantastic smells, and friendly folks to chat with. 5/5, all the way around.

Stopped in while passing through and bought one of each: classic chicken, bacon Mac and chocolate silk pie! ALL were excellent and we thoroughly enjoyed them! Only sorry we don’t live locally we would be here all the time!

We stopped into the bakery on our way to Petosky. Actually did a turn around as we drove past then turned back. This was the best pie I have ever tried. We also bought a few cookies, which were also the best I have ever had as well. The owner, baker was so nice and personable. If you’re ever in that area it’s a must try!!! Being from southeast Michigan we have achatz pies and his blew them out of the water.

My husband and I were vacationing in the area and just happened to drive past this shop and immediately turned around to buy some pie. We got slices of rhubarb, raspberry, and cherry/strawberry. The filling is so thick and the perfect balance of sweet and tart. I had never had a solely raspberry pie and it was delicious.