Murdick's Fudge and Ice Cream

Went by for an afternoon ice cream. The waffle cone was great and the two flavors I got were delicious! The pumpkin cheesecake ice cream was my favorite! Super creamy with large chunks of cheese cake. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a great ice cream experience.

We went in at almost 9 pm and they had quite the line, but they moved them through efficiently. The two young people working the counters were super nice and patient. It cost us $30 for two waffle cones, a small cake cone and a small cup, which seemed pricey. Other than that, it was good.

I think I was his first retail customer for Dec 2025. It appeared the store was closed for the season. I was skeptical about the ice cream and popcorn being fresh. I was surprised. Both were excellent. Worth going back or ordering online. Service was outstanding.

Owned by such an awesome family, this fudge and ice cream shop is a classic in downtown Petoskey! There is always a friendly face looking to help make your day more enjoyable. Grab some homemade ice cream and enjoy sitting in the park under a shade tree, down at the waterfront, or walk around town with it and enjoy the shops. Make sure you grab a bag of salt water taffy for the road!

Highly recommend! We loved the Petoskey stone and caramel latte ice cream. The mint in the Petoskey stone was perfect, not artificially flavored. They make all but their vegan ice cream in store! Sawyer was super helpful and gave us fantastic recommendations. We would totally return and try other flavors.