The Rusty Pig

My wife and I went here with friends who were visiting. I’ve never been and I’ve only heard good things about The Rusty Pig. The waitress was very kind and let us take our time with the menu. The acoustics of the restaurant made it a little difficult to hear. We had to talk louder than normal and lean forward. We were also seated next to other smaller occupied tables, where there were people seated already. If we had been spaced out a little bit more, that might have helped with the hearing. The first thing we decided to split was the Loaded Buffalo Pierogis. They were deliciously flavored and not too hot. All 4 of us ordered something different. I ordered The Pink Lady Chicken Sandwich with a side of Mac and cheese (because you HAVE to try that). They were both very yummy and filling. My

Great BBQ place! Food is top notch. The atmosphere and the service is good. What you would expect for the price. We have been here three times and every time left full and feeling good. A touch on the pricy side compared to some other local BBQ places but it is very good and very consistent so I think it is worth it. The Buffalo Chicken Perogies we had for an app stole the show. But everything has always been very good!

It’s the only BBQ in Seneca, and it was definitely a huge miss. Upon entering, a musty smell filled the humid space. Against my better judgement, we ordered (to go) and had a drink at the sticky bar while we waited. Was that a fly buzzing around or my imagination? Gave it two bites and couldn’t pretend it was edible. Hard pass.

Great place. We made a reservation for a Saturday night, and I strongly recommend this. When we arrived the outside and hostess area inside were packed with people waiting. We were seated immediately, and the hostess was really nice. Food was absolutely amazing. Garbage plate was enormous and unique. Also, cookie was awesome! Our server was nice too, but it took about a half hour to order drinks and receive them. It’s a smaller place, so you’d think servers would be on top of things shortly after being seated. She did run by saying she’d be over to order drinks asap. Luckily we were not in a hurry. After we received the drinks things moved fast. If it wasn’t for the long wait at the start I’d give this place 5 stars. Next time in the area we will be eating here again!

Good place with good food, the wait is crazy long , so we went to a Thai place nearby because we were starving and after that, when the wait was over, we went just to try. We ordered one portion of bbq with fries, meat was very tasty! Good beer on tap as well!