The Protein Bakery

We had an amazing experience at Protein Bakery! As the name suggests, they specialize in delicious protein-packed baked goods, and every bite was fresh, flavorful, and satisfying. Stephen, the owner, went above and beyond—he was kind, attentive, and genuinely helpful in making sure we found exactly what we wanted. His customer service alone is enough to earn our repeat business, and the quality of the products seals the deal. Highly recommend for anyone who wants treats that taste great and support their fitness goals!

During my last trip to NYC, I came across the Protein Bakery store. Since I love cookies and high protein foods, I was curios and decided to check them out. The Protein Bakery is officially my new obsession. I’ve tried several of their cookies and brownies, and every single one has been delicious — but a few totally stole the show. The Chocolate Chip Protein Brownie is rich and satisfying, the Peanut Butter Protein Blondie is pure comfort, and the Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Protein Cookie hits that perfect sweet‑salty balance. Not only are their treats incredible, but the whole experience is a vibe. Their store has a great assortment of cookies and brownies — truly something for every craving — and the associates are super friendly and helpful. And I have to mention this: their fabul

Dude. What the hell? I go across the street from this place for Pilates all the time and figured the treats were gross, but they’re amazing! Way better than any GNC protein bar, and the ingredients are fair (considering how these usually are). I am definitely coming back. Also customer service is good.

Stumbled on this bakery on a walk through the city and I’m so happy I went in! They have such a great variety of sweet treats - I have only tried the peanut butter chocolate chip cookies so far but have 2 blondies on deck. If they’re anything like the cookies, they’ll be 10/10. The owner was really cool and very nice. He has a very welcoming environment. I can’t wait to go back - they have a new customer for sure.

I love to give google reviews when deserved and PROTEIN BAKERY gets a 5 star. I would give more if possible. I have a subscription of a variety of protein bars. During the Holidays my package was opened and out of 25 cookies I received 6 as the box was opened. I sent an email to the company and Stephen responded back ASAP. Stephen was excellent in customer service and reassured me he would make it right. I followed the steps that Stephen had asked to take the resolved the problem. Stephen was so kind and would call me personally to followup. Thank you Protein Bakery for going over and beyond for your customers. I highly recommend them not only for the amazing product but for customer service!