Teresa's Pizza-Sagamore Hills

A very pleasant surprise. I was in need of a good meatball sandwich. This place delivered and upped the game. I added mushrooms and black olives. I wish I lived closer.

I tried to like this pizza… we have tried it a few times over a 2-3 year period. Yesterday was one of those times. I can’t get over the sauce. There is just something off about it. There is a bitterness I can’t adequately describe that just ruins the pizza for ME. The cheese, toppings, crust, all of that works. However it all comes down to the sauce. You may enjoy it. Clearly there are others that do. Don’t let me discourage you from trying it for yourself! The other thing that gets me is the Theresa’s in Maple uses a sauce that is the exact opposite of this. If they had the same sauce then this pizza would be 5x better.

White pizza. Good flavor with chunks of garlic. Young lady answering the phone and at the front desk needs more personable customer service.

Hands-down, the worst pizza and chicken wings I’ve ever had in my life. The wings were floating in Greece, and the pizza was uncooked. I didn’t think it was possible for wings and pizza to be un edible.

We called to order two house salads and an order of garlic bread with cheese. Was told their credit card machine was down and they could only take cash. I asked for no olives on my salad and they decided to not give me any cheese either. The garlic bread with cheese was a tiny slice of bread served iced cold. We called to let them know that the salad was made incorrectly, and the bread was lacking. They offered to deliver us another salad, then called 10 minutes later to say they were short on drivers and would not be delivering our correct salad. Awful customer service and food quality.