Sweet Avenue Bake Shop

This a cute shop and I was excited to try their products. They seperate the gluten free and non gluten items, which is great. The cake balls/ cookies/doughnuts/cupcakes all looked fantastic . Unfortunately the shop had an odd smell that I have encountered before in vegan bakeries. Still no idea what it is and you can taste it in the food . I was suspicious at that point and only ordered a few things. The cake balls probably weighed a pound each and had an odd texture, almost like wet dough. They were overly sweet. The doughnuts were also heavy, but somehow the driest thing I have ever tasted. Get the water ready. You will need it. My husband got a cookie and said it had the weird taste to it. It's 2025, other vegan/gluten free bakeries in NJ have their products down to science, with the pr

Amazing!!! Will be our go to bakery! Was looking for an eggless bakery for my daughter’s birthday cake due to her egg allergy when I found this place on google and gave them a shot and they did not disappoint. Everyone at the party asked about where i got the cake from. It was the most rich, moist and flavorful cake i’ve eaten. They were also able to match the picture I sent them. Thank you!!

I am gluten free and we ordered a gluten free cake for a celebration. Well I have to say it was terrible and my guests wouldn’t even eat it. It was so dry and flaky and it had a very weird taste. On top of that they charge $55 and $60 for the cakes. I was so embarrassed. I also called the bakery to tell the manager and whomever I spoke to just brushed it off that is how their cakes taste all the time. Not worth the money and the taste is terrible, I almost chocked trying to swallow the cake that’s how dry and flaky and with no taste either just a weird funny taste. I rarely complain about this but for my gluten free vegan people there are better bakeries than this one. I wouldn’t waste the money it’s expensive and you would need a gallon of water to get it down. The Oreos even tasted stale

We ordered a custom cake for a birthday party. The store took personal interest in the story behind the design and put on a personal touch and care that was beyond our exceptions. Clearly, there is a team here that not only showcases a strong baking and gorgeous design capabilities, but also a level of service and attention to details that is superb. This is the hallmark of a business that not only knows and takes pride in what they do, but also goes above and beyond in making their customers happy. Brilliant work.

This place is haven on earth! Not only for vegans but also health conscious people who have a sweet tooth like me! I felt like a kid in a candy store. Literally! The owners are super friendly and very helpful.. Love, love the taste too. Thank you Sweet Avenue Bake Shop. Rutherford is lucky to have you :)