GoodieBox Bakeshop

Carrie’s cakes are the best: moist, light, and flavorful. I ordered cakes from her for my daughter’s last 2 birthdays, and am about to order for the 3rd year in a row!

Carrie is such a wonderful baker and person! I’ve had the pleasure to work with her for a few cakes now and they are always so delicious and beautiful. This past weekend we celebrated my nephews baptism and she made a strawberry filling cake and wow ! Everyone loved it. We were all so happy . Thank you again

GoodieBox Bakeshop made a special Knicks-themed cake for my son’s 5th birthday at the American Dream Mall Waterpark. The ordering process was simple and efficient — a quick call with the owner, Carrie, and she immediately understood what we wanted. She coordinated directly with the American Dream team on logistics, delivery, and presentation time, making the entire process seamless and stress-free. When the cake was unboxed, the kids were buzzing with excitement. The cake itself was excellent — beautifully designed, very fairly priced, and enjoyed by all. It proved so popular that my wife and I didn’t even get a slice, and we received many compliments on the flavor. Even our son, who usually only eats the frosting, finished his entire piece. We look forward to ordering from GoodieBox Bak

Working with Carrie was such a piece of cake. We discussed details of a birthday cake over email and she was very attentive and responsive. Finally she made a cake that didn't just look pretty as per our asks but also tasted amazingly good!

It was amazing working with Carrie. She was quick to respond to emails, and really followed through on the design of the cake. The lemon raspberry tasted wonderful, not super sweet, and just the right amount of tart. Would absolutely work with them again.