Sugarloaf Frostie

Sugarloaf Frostie has been a favorite my whole life. Reasonably price, great tasting food - whether it's a burger, grinder, salmon sandwich, fries or anything else on the menu. The soft serve and hard ice cream are also a hit. The only thing to know is it is a cash only. business. Updating in 2025: still as awesome as ever.

Expensive price. We ordered large fries ($7) and chicken tenders ($10). A cup of fries and 4 tenders shouldn't be $17. We then got a small soft serve for $4.50. It tasted like a soft serve.

This place has gotten so mid. It used to be good, but now it's definitely not giving. The mozzarella sticks were actual sticks now, they are big balls so when my grandma and I took a bite of it, there was an ice cube of cheese inside. The hotdogs used to be so good, now they are just good. Same about the hamburger. Getting the macaroni balls was a big mistake. This whole meal was insanely expensive for down graded quality. Good service though.

One of the best places to get soft serve ice cream as well of a wide variety of hard serve ice cream and food that includes sea food like sandwiches hot dogs and drinks... It's also on the bus route in the 31 that goes to sunderland. It opens up at 11 am and they take cash only for payment

I've been here a few times when visiting Mt. Sugarloaf & I must be honest, it's not the cheapest or fastest place for ice cream/food...however, I did give a decent review, because they do have a variety of tasty sweet treats & other good food to eat! First off, I will tell you a small sundae here costs $9! That's a bit pricey in my opinion. I could see $5-$7, but almost $10? Also very important to know, this restaurant only accepts cash, no credit or other forms of payment accepted! It bothered me that this was not posted in a more noticeable way! As you approach the counter to order, you'll see very small signs that read "Cash Only!" I would be pretty upset to wait such a long time only to get up to place my order & realize that they don't accept credit, if I only was carrying cards & no