Stone House Tavern

This place was so good, by the time I realised I should've taken a photo of my food I already ate it. (Luckily I remembered to take a pic of my dessert) The staff was so unbelievably kind and friendly. The atmosphere was extremely cozy. The food was mouthwatering!!! The pineapple juice - freshly squeezed. The french fries - hand cut. (Finally a place with fries that don't have a pasty texture. The outside was crunchy and they weren't even greasy 😍) I ordered the buttermilk chicken sandwich, and I couldn't have gotten a more perfectly prepared sandwich. Everything was beautiful. AND they were busy the night we came, yet service was quick and no sloppily prepared food. The quality of the food is unbelievable a delight. I think this is the best restaurant I've ever went to.

Great diner / tavern to stop by if you are in the Lake Minnewaska area. Fresh, flavorful food, good selection of brews. Interesting decor. Polite, professional staff. We needed to stop for lunch and this was a wonderful choice thanks to great reviews before us.

Loved this place! The food was so good. I didn’t get any of the entrees, but they looked amazing (just a little pricey). The crispy Brussels sprouts and chicken wings with blueberry BBQ sauce were out of this world! The Buddha Bowl and Philly Steak wrap were super tasty. Our server Connie was awesome - super friendly, attentive, and made us feel really welcomed!

We dined, haven't been here in about 45 yrs! It has changed hands a couple times since it was Traficanti's Italian Family Restaurant. It was great then, great now. Tofu Wings are to die for, so was green beans almondine. Wings (5) were very filling. Wasn't crazy about the Butternut Squash Bisque though. Brown Butter Gnocchi had an unexpected tang to it. Mac and Cheese was good. A bit noisy with 2 very large tables next to us. Service was pleasant and very attentive. Guinness was delicious. Reservations strongly suggested as this place is very popular. We will be back to try other dishes, and we will bring friends!

We made a reservation for the dinner and had to adjust it couple of times due to the traffic, and the tavern was very helpful accommodating it on what appeared to be busy mid-October early evening Friday. The service and the food were outstanding (markedly better than typical NYC joint), so it was a pleasant surprise. The restaurant is slightly more on the expensive side, but overall experience made it worthwhile.