Stoltzfus BBQ

Inside of the Amish & Columbus Farmer's Market. A savory tender brisket with side of sweet corn 😋 On the salty side but sweet BBQ sauce balances it out.

Nestled inside the Amish building of the Columbus Flea Market, the ever present 10 minute line is testament to the quality and quantity of food you’ll get. We ordered the chicken and ribs platter for $12 and shared. The mashed potatoes were smooth as silk, the Mac and cheese better than anything I can make at home, and the ribs in a word, sublime. Served cafeteria style the staff is warm and friendly. You can also order take out to go, the couple next to us was ordering enough to feed a regiment. It’s in the sticks but totally worth the trip for the food alone.

Affordable, tasty place to grab a quick bite to eat. We got the brisket sandwich with soup. It came with potato chips as well. The slice of brisket was delicious, although too large to be eaten as a sandwich. It melted in your mouth, but had a lot of excess fat. Service was fast and pleasant. There was a lot of tables open for seating. For the price, I would definitely return.

Everything was delicious! There was so much to select from. I chose to get a BBQ wing platter with 2 sides which were Mac and cheese and roasted potatoes. The mac and cheese was just ok but I didn't expect it to be so much, it wasn't as cheesy it just takes like noodles with creamy cheese sauce and very wet in texture, but it was edible but I probably wouldn't get it again. The roasted potatoes were very good, exactly how it sounds. I also picked, a kielbasa, which was very good. A smoked turkey leg, delicious and juicy. A side of green beans, just tasted steamed or boiled a bit with maybe butter in it but it was just ok in my opinion, I liked the texture not the flavor as it wasn't much to it, just basic green beans. I also, picked a side order of wings, which I received the bbq and the

Everything was super good and fresh. The mashed potatoes were outstanding. There’s always a long line but it moves pretty quickly. Highly recommend.