Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream

Definitely one of the best ice cream places on the Cape. If you like hot fudge sundaes, I personally don't think you'll find better. My friend came to visit and said he had the best banana split he's ever had. My wife is a regular:( .My friends banana split. They make home made whipped cream. They only thing you might encounter. On a busy night ,depending on the server, it may be smaller than usual. Its on the higher end for price. So, you deserve to get the full portion. Smitty himself is a great guy and down to earth. We have been going there since the day it opened. So, my wife loving ice cream, thats a statement in itself. Her favorite place on the Cape for ice cream.

We had quite the selection today! Most of their flavors are available but they are not fully ready with all flavors. We were all happy with our ice cream cones, ice cream sundaes and root beer floats. Yummy! Mine could have been a little bit fresher. It felt a little bit stale/icy. But it certainly hit the spot. 😋 🍨 💰💲 THIS IS CASH ONLY This i place is right at the rotary. Easy to find if you're looking out for it but it gets very busy here on the cape. This place gets packed in the summer so prepare yourself time wise. If you have found my review helpful please give me a thumbs up 👍 and feel free to follow me for future reviews. #Cape #CapeCod

I love to support local. But they never carry rainbow sprinkles EVER. Very expensive Ice cream and cash only. Went again recently asked for hot fudge and peanut butter in my Sunday only got peanut butter. I’m happy to pay for the additional topping but never given it. The ice cream it’s self is delicious but they never have rainbow sprinkles and they don’t listen when you ask for special requests or something specific.

BEST COOKIE DOUGH! If you like your cookie dough ice cream with a ton of cookie dough pieces this is the place to go!!! They also have homemade waffle cones !

We wanted to try their blueberry ice cream but they didn't have any that day so got an orange pineapple scoop instead. Just loved it. Felt very natural and homemade. Their store is also very cute, with benches to sit outside.