Sift Bake Shop Mystic

Such a gem! The desserts were absolutely beautiful and they tasted just as incredible as they looked. The display case was so impressive, it honestly made it hard to choose. Everything looked fresh and crafted with care. I’ll definitely be back soon to make my way through more of the menu.

Staff was friendly and attentive. The bake goods were fantastic. I am a bogeta bacon egg and cheese type of guy. The cheaper establishment tend to have the better sandwiches in my opinion. This is a rare occasion where I have to go against my own opinion. Their egg sandwich on a croissant is worth the $11 price point. Their cookies are worth are worth too and huge. I recommend 15 seconds in the microwave for the best tasting results. Their breads are also exceptional. Overall 9.5/10 experience. Protip- Go early and beat the crowds

We planned to visit the bakery many months ago due to the rave reviews. We were there on the morning on a weekend during rain, but there was still a big line for dine in, which is the same for pickup as well. Apparently you can only pick up without the line for bulk orders. The line moved fast so it was good. I was able to order based on the items on display. All croissants were tasty and a single croissant is very filling, vegetable croissant was savoury and tasty, pecan bun is very sweet and yum, only one type of brownie was available which was extremely fudgy and tasty, blueberry scone was dry and wished they served it with butter, and the macarons were out of this world. It is a quick service restaurant and you grab the order to dine on your own. There was good number of seats to dine

When I go to Mystic, it’s a must to stop at Sift! This is an amazing bakery. There are so many pastries to choose from. Everything is fresh, beautifully prepared, and the taste is outstanding. The pastry breads melt in your mouth good! The place is always busy and crew serves you quickly. The only thing I would change is the set up when you order. This isn’t a sit down and order place, more of a coffee shop model. There really isn’t enough time to read the menu and look for what drink or food items (in cases) that your eyes, tummy, and heart desires. The way the cases are set up are very awkward and you feel rushed when ordering, especially when there’s a long line behind you. If it’s cold outside, make sure to bundle up because you will have to wait outside in the line. This will be wort

Very good bakeshop in Mystic! Lines are long but if you have the time to wait, it’s worth trying something. We had the chocolate chip cookie, guava cheese danish, and chocolate croissant. The chocolate croissant was most notable because it has chocolate on both the inside and outside!! 😋