Shay's Pie Place

First off, if you’re on the fence about buying from here, get off the fence immediately and go. It’s hands down the best place ever. I’ve had the cake pops, tres leches, and the baked Nutella cheesecake and they are so good and amazing for the price. Seriously the best ever. Staff are always nice and Shay herself is also amazing.

The pies are fresh and taste amazing. The home cooked meals are healthy, nutritious and yummy. 😋 (Get their monthly calendar) The service and atmosphere are always warm, friendly and inviting.

We were tasked with providing pie for our large Thanksgiving family party this year. Not having the time, the experience, nor the desire to make the pie myself, we ordered a couple last-minute from Shay's Pie Place. I've had their pie in the past and know several people who get their baked goods exclusively through Shay's, so I knew we were in good hands. The pies turned out great and were loved by everyone. I hear the pumpkin pie was great (I didn't try it), and their strawberry rhubarb pie is a personal favorite. This place is great! Highly recommended, and they're a great local small business to support for any of your baked dessert needs.

I had never been to Shay’s pie place when I called them about catering for my wedding reception. Shay was so kind and had lots of good information! The prices were very reasonable and there were many flavors of pie to choose from! Very satisfied with the pies and the wedding guests loved them! I have less than a dozen at the end of the night! So yummy!

So Delicious! Everything I have had from Shay has been amazing. You can taste the love, and you can tell she uses quality ingredients. She has Pies and all different kinds of treats. She even has a daily meal, that is home made. We did an event, where she helped us make our own pies. It was a ton of fun!