Sgt. Pepperoni​'s

Every time I go to Bayfield going to Sgt. P's is an absolute must! Some of the best pizza I have ever had. Staff is always friendly and even gave my dad a nickname cuz of frequent we go. If you are a local or tourist, this is the place to eat in Bayfield!

Stopped here in Sept 2023, the place itself is carry out or delivery, BUT you can go next door to Greunke's Inn and order their pizza for dine in. I loved the word play with the Beatles SGT. Pepper, so we had to try it. Was not disappointed

a little hole in the wall place like we used to have back in our home town, so I knew it would be good. Pizza was very good 👍 sad we didn't have room to finish it or time for left overs!

I guess you get what you pay for here (based on the Google$ signs). I spent $20 on a small “Summer Special” not only do they use canned ingredients such as their mushrooms, but they leave you waiting on their front steps after their pizza has been made for 20 minutes instead of bring it out to you. Apparently they don’t care if they stay if you stay at their lodging, no discount and no better service. I guess it serves as a good reminder not to tip in advance for service! Ignore those tip jars make them work to serve!

Delicious pizza!!! The crust was consistent with the crunch to chewy ratio. There was the perfect amount of cheese, toppings and sauce. I was very happy with the staff experience and the food. Great place to stop in.