Scalini Fedeli Montville

Outstanding Experience – Truly Michelin-Level This restaurant truly deserves all the praise it gets. I’ve been to their New York location, which holds a Michelin star, and I can honestly say the Montville, New Jersey location delivers the same level of excellence. From the moment we walked in, everything felt welcoming, professional, and refined. The food was absolutely incredible — perfectly balanced flavors, high-quality ingredients, and beautifully presented. Every dish felt thoughtfully prepared, just like you’d expect from a top Italian restaurant. The service was exceptional. Our server Trisha was absolutely wonderful — warm, attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely kind. She made the entire experience even better with her professionalism and great energy. You can tell she truly ca

Immediately you arrive at the most beautiful inn that they had all decorated for fall. The hostess was so kind and warm when we entered the restaurant. Our whole party wasn't there at the same time, so we grabbed a drink at the bar; extra points for having backs on all the bar seats which is so much more comfortable. Amanda the bartender was SPECTACULAR! She had so much knowledge of different drinks and spirits, was kind, and made a delicious drink. She started our dinner journey off perfectly. We were sat in a corner cozy booth/round table and the price fix menu made it easy to dine with another couple and all be able to chose your own dishes. All of the food and presentation were delicious and incredible. They were flexible with everything and for all being first time diners here it was

If I could give 10 stars I would. What a wonderful dining experience. My husband and I chose to eat here to celebrate the New Year and we couldn't be more pleased. The service, food and drinks were impeccable. Each dish was delicious and elegantly presented. We can't wait to go back. Trish, it was lovely to meet you ♥️.

Went for the ravioli with egg yolk. Don’t realize it was a price fixe menu. Got so much food and it was all delicious. Lovely bar for pre dinner cocktails

Came here for my birthday and Beth our server was amazing! It was a prefix menu with a set price. The substitutes are there for a small fee. The bruschetta was amazing! The prosciutto was great too. The zucchini was amazing. Garlicky, crunchy not very spicy! I skipped the Parmesan because of the vinegrette. I HATE seafood but omg the smoked salmon was amazing it tasted like bacon! I was shocked! The bread was great. The garlic bread had a bit of spice kick to it. The fresh tomatoe mini pizza thing was my favorite. I got the porcini mushroom and my husband got the vodka! Both were to die for! So full of flavor and rich. Forgot to take a picture of the shrimp but that was also amazing! I got the steak and it was ok. Nothing special. The fries were delicious. Right amount of crunchy and salt.