Columbia Inn

The Columbia Inn is my Cheers bar/restaurant. I like sitting at the bar where you can eat at the bar and it’s also great for people watching. The bar tenders are awesome! They are closed on Monday with food and drink specials on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. I really like their thin crust pizzas but everything on the menu is great! We had a sausage and onion pizza (top) and a chicken parm pizza (bottom). We also had a Cesar’s salad and the fried calamari. Note: I add photos periodically w/o updating the review

Every time I go here I feel like I hit a home run on Dinner. I usually start off with a cup of their Stracciatella Soup which is phenomenal. Then I order one of these famous thin crust pizza pies and absolutely demolish the entire pie within 10 minutes. It’s so easy to crush one of their pies to your head and you don’t feel like moosh afterwards at all. Honestly, me writing this review is making me crave one of those pies right now. For those wondering as they read this review….”is this guy like 500lbs or something?”. No way jose, I’m just a huge fan of Columbia Inn and felt it was time to leave a review on here. Go try out their pizza…you’ll thank me later!

I was excited to try the thin crust pizza, as I’ve heard good things. This pie was very disappointing. You pay additional for each topping and there were next to no onions and the meatballs were also barely there, with some slices having nothing on them. It was thin but not crispy even after reheating. I would rate the pizza a 3/10. There are many other great spots for a good thin crust pie in the area, this is just not one of them. In my opinion!

The food here is so amazing but the real MVP is Scott at the bar! The drinks are perfect just like the pizza and rest of the food. Service is great. Gets packed, make a reservation. Tuesday is half off pizza and you can’t beat it! Laid back atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Columbia Inn restaurant have really good home made thin crust pizza and home kind atmosphere, first time came here with my sister’s family as they leave in Montville NJ. Service is good as well. Definitely one of the best pizza I ever ate.