Sarah's Alley Cake Co.

Sarah is absolutely amazing. She has been making my cakes for years, and they are always stunning, and they taste great. From my wedding cake, to birthday cakes, cookie cakes, cupcakes, cookies and pies. It’s never a disappointment. What makes it even better is that Sarah is so kind and treats you like family. She listens, she makes sure you feel heard, and the results…..TOP TIER. As long as I am here in town, I’ll never use anyone else:):)

I ordered some custom cookies for my daughter’s KPDH themed birthday and they were amazing! So soft and delicious, perfectly baked and beautifully decorated. Ordering was easy too. Sarah is so talented! She really nailed it! 10/10 recommend!

Received one of Alleys cakes for my birthday last year and have been hooked since! Same delicious cake each time. Easy to order from and quick pickup service. The martini cake is from my birthday and the other is from my daughter’s birthday. My daughter added the bows to hers last minute so don’t judge Alley for that 😊.

We went to Sarah about a month ago looking to have a custom cake made for our son’s first birthday. We told her the general vibes we were going for (Lord of the Rings themed) but we couldn’t really decide what direction to take it. After looking at some set photos, we zeroed in on the Shire and Sarah locked in. When we picked it up this past weekend, we were AMAZED at the quality and detail. We’ve seen her work and knew it would be something beautiful, but she blew our expectations out of the water! I can not recommend Sarah’s Alley Cake Co. enough!

Sarah is the best! She made the cakes for our wedding and we got so many comments on how good the cake was! She took my vision (really I had nothing) and turned it into something beautiful!