Rutherford Coffee Co.

I’m struggling to describe how good the pastries are. I’m a big fan of Columbia food, but was never really able to find baked goods that delicious. My friend recommended it to me saying that they have one of the best arepas. And omg that’s true. 10/10 would recommend to anyone thinking about stopping by for a coffee and a snack in Rutherford

I was greeted in this cute spot by friendly staff. Then I enjoyed a delicious BEC on a cheese pandebono (sooo good) and the best French vanilla latte!! Also - loved the Spanish music in the background, it was a nice ‘perk in the morning. ☕️❤️

Very nice cafe. They use paper plane beans so the coffee is great and is well priced! Staff were very nice and welcoming. Space is clean and has fresh flowers on every table!! Great place to get some work done. We loved our drinks and will definitely come back. They have some Columbian pastries/drinks that seem really good. We’ll have to come back and try it.

UPDATE: I was so impressed by the delivery that I craved the sandwich the next day and brought my mom and daughter with me. We arrived at 428 pm... I asked if we could order and sit since they close at 5... they said yes but when I went to order a chicken salad toast they told me the kitchen was closed. 30 minutes before closing and u can't order food. Really sucks. Ordered the chick n fix toast. The best chicken salad hands down!!! The toast is the perfect combination of chicken salad, microgreens and I topped mine with crumbled bacon. 1000/10!! So good. It also got delivered in perfect condition. I washed it down with a milo coffee Frappuccino and it was delicious and refreshing. My new go to spot!

Really enjoy Rutherford Coffee Co.! I come here once per week to work remotely, and the atmosphere is pleasant without being too loud or crowded. Chai tea latte with almond milk is delicious, and the pan de bono bacon egg cheese is also a favorite. This shop reminds me of Rey Sol in Ridgewood, another great coffee shop but can be louder is not ideal for working remotely.