Romeo's Pizza

The food was great but what was even better was the service. We stayed at cricket hill cabins, (about 8 miles away) and they delivered out there. The driver was polite and respectful would definitely order again! The price was also right.

Best pizza in town in my opinion and there are a lot of competitors, only place that came close was Fox's Pizza Den which is now closed. Delivery was quick although the delivery man did have to call me to ask for clarification as to where exactly I live, but the neighborhood is confusing and there is no signage, so I understand that. Can't really speak on atmosphere as I did not dine in. I order from here quite often and it's always great, no complaints whatsoever.

It has great food, but the service is very... questionable is the best way to put it. The Romeo's app says that they're closed all the time so I have to use doordash which costs usually $10 more than the app. There was 1 time I ordered 4 garlic butter and got none of it. and also had a $5 discount which on the receipt only took off 2.50. It's my favorite place in Millersburg but those factors are making me question if I should keep supporting them.

Romeo's is definitely one of the....pizzas of the world. Its not good, and it's not bad. Its a pizza you get when you really don't feel like making Mac and cheese at home. The sauce - 3.5 If you're one of those weird people that likes sweet sauce, you'll like Romeo's. Now, I understood it was sweet going into my first bite, but holy cow was it sweet. Who dumped the maraschino cherries in with the tomatoes? The crust - 2 Have you ever microwaved a pizza, and really got it bubbling, and then let it cool down before eating it? You remember how tough the crust was, but at the same time it was still soft? Yeah. You could tell me the crust wasn't microwaved, and I'd call you a dirty liar. BUT, it was consistent. It was crusted, and crunchy around the edge, and flat under the sauce. The look - 4

I love their signiture sweet sauce, it's addicting. They also run great deals that's hard to resist. We order almost weekly for several years now, but today's order looks like a medium pizza in a large box. (I ordered a large) It was put in the middle and spread out to look like the correct size. But is it? The slices look smaller... So has the box changed or was this a mistake?