PrimoHoagies

Love this location. First of all, sandwiches are delicious with a HUGE selection of cheeses and meats. This is awesome when so many chains are going down to just provolone. 🫤 Just really good, well-made sandwiches with quality ingredients and great bread. The service at this location is outstanding. The staff are fast, friendly, and thorough. They have somehow NEVER messed up an order. I've ordered a lot. That's impressive. When I order online, my sandwich is always ready when I go in for pickup. So glad we have PrimoHoagies in Mahwah!

Went today for the first time. Ordered a turkey and sharp provolone, it was great and plentiful. Great service from the young guy making the sandwich. Will definitely return. 3/25.. Another great sandwich today. Met Joe the owner, very friendly. You gotta try this great sandwich shop. The bread is amazing. Thank you Joe and staff for a great sandwich and chips.

Heard good things about this place but was very disappointed. I ordered a turkey sandwich and a spicy Italian. I got two spicy Italians. I was the only person in the store from the second I walked and even when I walked out, and it was wrong. I’d love to know what they believe to be “capicola” cause I saw a lot of “ham” which was most definitely not capicola. The only reason I give the food two stars is the bread.

Words can’t describe how delicious it is here! The bread is so fresh and soft with a ton of flavor. I tried a few items and the Roast Pork was to die for. The cookies too OMG so amazing!

I'm always met with really great service every time I come here for lunch, so much so that it's worth a review! Sandwiches are delicious as well, particularly the diabolos.