Polly's Variety Store

The Chewy Deluxe is my favorite, so far! I have more to try. Great spot to stop in and grab a bite with tables and a little barside seating too! New to the area and this is definitely my new favorite place to pop into.

Not enough pep topping. And the bottom of the pizza was burnt. Yuck! The whole pizza was not good and flavorless. Pollys I'd love to reply to you, but that isn't an option. This pizza was ordered on Monday 2/26 at 12:10pm ( they were not busy).

Visited during a road trip from CT to Maine, and got some free pizza, cookie, and a lotto ticket. Had to say no to the free hot chocolate and meeting with Santa since we're on a time constraint but it was absolutely amazing! 10/10

This is exactly what you would hope for in a market like this. You have the sassy chef, and the regulars coming in and out. There is limited bar seats, but those look like they are there while you wait for your food. I think it would be awkward if you sat down to eat there. We got a Rubin, ultimate grilled cheese, jalapeño poppers, broccoli poppers and a piece of cake. All of them were good, and while the grilled cheese was unique (bacon, cheese, cheese sticks, and sweet chili sauce) all of the fried food that we ordered got a bit too heavy. I hope to be able to try a couple other items, especially the pizza.

Called to make sure that their ATM was working they said if it’s not we’ll give you cash back instead, ok cool! Walked all the way there, the ATM had an error and they don’t take EBT. Next time you should just tell people the truth when they call you and then maybe then they could pay for their sandwiches, I guess I’m not the asshole in this situation. 🙄🤦🏽‍♀️ Still a shop I go to a lot though, Great food great atmosphere, great staff. I’m sorry I had you cook for no reason.