Plumsteadville Inn

Absolutely love this place! When we visit we are greeted with smiles and impeccable hospitality from the hosts. One host stands out everytime- Bryce! He is always so kind and welcoming. We sat in the garden room with Kayla who was very attentive and knowledgeable. The sweet and spicy chicken is always delicious and we even recieved half off this time for customer appreciation month! Thanks Plumsteadville!! You can never beat this place.

If you’re anywhere near Plumsteadville and looking for a place that feels like home the moment you walk in, Plumsteadville Inn is it. From the second you step through the doors, you’re wrapped in a warm, inviting atmosphere that perfectly blends historic charm with relaxed comfort. The lighting is just right, the energy is lively without being overwhelming, and there’s this unmistakable sense that everyone—regulars and first-timers alike—belongs there. The bar is truly the heartbeat of the place. Paul and Carol set the tone with incredible skill and personality. Paul mixes every drink to pure perfection while keeping the energy upbeat and engaging, and Carol brings warmth, humor, and that rare ability to make every guest feel like a VIP. And the talent doesn’t stop there. De, Janel, and

If I were to rate this inn with the warm hospitable welcoming of Deni, I would give it a 10plus. On the other hand, Jason would receive a ZERO. He was abrupt, rude and annoyed at any question or inconvenience related to a problem. |The room itself was okay, although I did see debris on the sheets - were they changed? It was extremely noisy both nights of my stay. Dragging of chairs and tables to reset the conference room was a bit much after a long travel day and wanting quiet rest. |I saw other older reviews complained about the shower being hard to adjust and went from hot to ice cold. This problem was never fixed. |The restaurant was very good. Do try Deni’s amazing pretzels! The restaurant and events are definitely priorities over the guest rooms. I would not stay here again!

We just spent 2 nights here this weekend in 2 suites for 2 couples. We all raved about this place all the way home back to upstate NY. From the food, to the accomodations, to the wonderful personal attention from all the staff! Jason was exceptional to be so accommodating since we showed up on the early side. He was a busy guy but always pleasant with all of us! We so appreciate his hospitality. The Saturday night dinner and music in the tavern was super! The best was Sunday Brunch with Santa, we had no reservation and sat at the bar .It was the biggest buffet I had ever seen! Prime Rib, to omelette station, chocolate fountain and everything in between! The staff was so friendly, they even remembered us from The 1st evening we were there! Loved this place rating 10++ we will be back for su

Went for Valentines Day and it was so busy but well organized. My wife and I tried some of the Valentines Day specials and they were terrific. Emily waited on us and she was very personable. We even got complimentary chocolate strawberries and champagne. We want to come back again for our date nights.