Plaza Diner

Decided to go here as it had really good reviews and I love classic diner’s. To me it looks like an old friendly’s restaurant just painted. Inside it gives off the cozy appearance and a local spot. Server very friendly and was the table quickly. Drinks came back quickly and ordered food. The milkshakes were great so I had high hopes for the food. Wife ordered the waffle, I tried it and was ok not impressed as it was soggy not crispy. I had the Rueben panini with the macaroni salad. I must say the macaroni salad was homemade and good after I added salt and pepper, that is a matter of taste. The Rueben was odd as I have never had a panini that used like a Sam’s club flatbread. Not for me and wasn’t impressed as I love Rueben’s. Son ordered the other Rueben and wasn’t impressed with the bread

Great diner with an awesome breakfast menu. I had the French toast and split the meat, one fast sausage link and one browned patty. Topped with whipped cream and fruit and a fried egg on the side. My waitress was friendly and accommodating. If I lived nearby I’d be eating there regularly.

We happened upon this place on our way to Cooperstown and what a gem! Service top notch, friendly staff, fresh and delicious salad bar and every plate we ordered was delicious!!! Fresh made everything! If you’re near here, eat here!

$3 for a cup of coffee that was only about half full in the cup. Handed me a plate of french toast with basically mouth fulls of cinnamon on top of each piece. Absolute disappointment. The girl tried replacing it. I said no. Im not paying for it. I would have been better off not eating at all.

Lovely lunch at Plaza Diner in their new location. The salad bar remains a great choice. The space is bright and welcoming. This is a Greek diner so you can't go wrong choosing a Greek entree. We had a relaxed lunch with attentive staff. Will return again.