Pizza Paul's

The pizza place in our town changed their recipe and we don’t love it, so we’ve been trying to find another place for our weekly pizza order. We’ve ordered from Pizza Paul’s Geneseo location a few times and it’s been a challenge to get a decent pizza. We always order light sauce. The first time we were given white sauce. There was so much garlic in that sauce on that pizza that it was absolutely inedible. It leaked all through the box and all over my car on the way home. When I called they did remake it but unfortunately I’d driven 20 mins home and then had to go 20 mins back for the remade pizza. The remade one was decent enough for us to try again. Once again we ordered light sauce, and the picture of the pizza attached is what we were provided. We’re literally mopping the sauce up with

Whoever made the calzones on 4/23 around 6:30 should NEVER be allowed to make them again. First off the cheese isn’t even melted second of all I think they used a whole bottle of seasoning on top. I scraped half of it off already. This is absurd. It tastes AWFUL. I’ve had amazing calzones here but this is not it. Please reteach this person on how to make them

Overpriced. The extra large is a standard large everywhere else, and it was $30 for a standard cheese, and pepperoni. Visually, it looks decent when you open the box. Cheese looked like it was barely melted, or if someone grated a block of great value over the pie. The sauce tastes like it came from a can, and over-seasoned. Too salty. I will say that the crust was good! Do yourself a favor, and order across the street. It looks like a train wreck inside, and smells like the place is about to catch fire, but the pizza is leaps and bounds above whatever I tasted here. One of the better qualities is that the staff was friendly.

Perfectly cooked pizza and wings. Fast service. Great prices. Can you ask for anything better? I love the flavor of the BBQ wings and the crust is PERFECT. We get pizza here weekly. We have never had a bad experience. I miss the late owner but his crew is still going strong. See you next week!!

We love this place. Having an autistic son we are constantly dealing with his picky easting. I decided to choose my battles but consistently offer new foods to try. In the meantime he loves garlic bread with cheese. They've gotten to know us and have even made a large version for him. Also the regular pizza and wings are also great.