Pizza My Heart

Pizza My Heart is one of those spots you just have to visit when you’re in the area—it’s an absolute must. For me, it’s like Southern comfort food, but in pizza form. The pizza is always flavorful, the crust is perfect, and the sauce is amazing. The staff is friendly, the vibe is chill, and even the salads are top-notch. One of the coolest things is the “slice and a T-shirt” combo—grab a fresh slice and some fresh merch for just nine bucks. It’s the perfect way to rep the brand and enjoy great food at the same time. I stop by every time I’m in town, and it never disappoints. Five-star pizza all the way. Highly recommend!

Honestly you CANNOT go to Capitola and not get at least one slice... You have two locations and personally the one not by the beach is sneaky sneaky... You can have your Pizza in peace and sit down to chill... Honestly always fire!!

Absolutely phenomenal pizza. The Watsonville had incredible flavor and was perfectly balanced, and the Sweet Heat was next level — the sweet and spicy combo was done just right. You can tell the ingredients are fresh and the dough is on point. We finished with the cinnamon dessert pizza and it did not disappoint.

My son was eating a slice and thought a hair was in his food.. Turns out it was a RUBBER BAND. I understand these things happen however this was a 5 year old child that could’ve easily chocked, please make sure your staff is more aware as this is a huge health concern!

Got a couple slices of pizza : both burnt , 1 was a Hawaiian type slice , the other was a supreme type option . The supreme type had barely any topping on it . Grew up in Santa Cruz so this isn’t my first time eating this pizza . Staff were stand offish in regards to the barely visible topping see pic for reference. Blamed the cooks instead of just apologizing for a $6 dollar slice of pizza with barely any toppings on it. Idk where the manger was but clearly training need to done to have appropriate customer service . To communicate with the other staff. Super dry pizza had the most minimal of sauces . Definitely don’t recommend this location. Go to the original locations in downtown Santa Cruz or at Capitola Village.