Pie In the Sky

Love Pie in the Sky! Always fresh and delicious. Wish I could eat there every day. The calzones are incredible- and they're mega-sized. So, so good. The best I've ever had.

One of the best place to get pizza in Saint Albans! Went during lunch time. It was pretty busy but it only took couple minutes for us to get seated. We had the large pineapple passion pizza ($24.99). It was good and fresh! Soda was actually good and not flat. Our server was nice and attentive. Nice atmosphere with good choice of music. It’s a busy place for sure!

Pizza has been perfect every time that we’ve visited. Recently visited in January 2026 and brought my parents to try. We got the pepperoni pizza for my kids and the Cuban pizza for us. The waiter was very friendly and checked in regularly. We really enjoy coming here for food as we pass through saint albans. If you haven’t been, we highly recommend it!

Pretty awesome place. We stopped in on a business trip. I wasn't a super fan of the pizza sauce (reminded me of spaghetti sauce) but it was still pretty good. Super friendly staff. I cant wait to try other items on the menu.

I know Dennis appreciates feedback so I only post this with the hopes it gets resolved. We have visited the restaurant many times over the years and the order we received was the worst I’ve ever had. I ordered a meatball bowl three meatballs with onions and peppers and cheese . The food was lukewarm warm at best very few vegetables a few pieces of cheese on top and the sauce was lukewarm warm and only came up to half of the meatballs. Three pieces of cold garlic bread.