Peter's Diner

Went with a big party on a Saturday night and there was space was us. I would say we were around 8+ guests. Food was fine. But the service was really subpar. Idk what happened. They just weren't very attentive at all. Which is strange seeing as they were making a lot of money off of us. They managed to get a couple of things wrong with our orders- but we didn't care enough to complain. Wouldn't really recommend. There are much better diners alone on the island and probably nearby too.

The food was delish! I loved the Greek omelet with a side of grits. The atmosphere was cozy and festively decorated for the holidays. The staff was friendly and enthusiastic about the holiday season as well. I love that this diner is a long-standing part of Amityville history!

A perfect little diner. Plenty of parking, stairs or ramp to enter. Greeted warmly by the owner and seated immediately. Friendly servers bring hot coffee and fresh food. Small, very clean restaurant. Diners and staff all seemed very happy. ♿️

I stopped here for lunch after walking around Amityville and it was really good. I had a gyro platter and chicken soup and a very friendly waitress. I think she said it was only her second day. Nice diner and I would definitely go back.

Nice little diner. Pretty standard menu. I got breakfast. Very happy with my omelette. Home fries were really good too as were the pancakes. Staff was very friendly. Place was clean. Will go back if I’m in the area.