Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli

What a fun place. I need to start this with the overwhelming (good) hospitality. You are taken care of when you come here. I discovered this place today and I am happy that i stopped. Every. One. Is. Friendly. They also have a fun shop corner for jellys. Check it out. Tasting station. I was genuinely surprised on how popular the spot was...and i hope it keeps growing. I really enjoyed my experience here. Vintage lunchboxes are a thing and they capture it well. Check them out. Make a day of it. Great for dates, families and whatever you want #pb&j

PB and J elevated to greatness 🙂. Fun establishment with very friendly staff. Quite the variety of jellies to choose from for your sandwich. Reasonable prices.

Really cool place to visit. The sandwich was very sweet. The milkshake was delicious.

I'll start out by saying I typically don't like peanut butter. However, I got the Tiny Tins for West Allis and there was one for Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli. So I figured I'd use it and check it out. Oh, was I so pleasantly surprised! The sandwiches were absolutely amazing! I never thought I'd go somewhere for a pb&j but yum, it was so worth it. Not only were the sandwiches fantastic, the staff is so friendly, and the atmosphere is so nostalgic. I love everything about it. I also love how much they are out in the community. Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli participates in all the events with a booth to taste test (blocktober fest, the farmers market, and many others that I have seen them at). Highly recommend!!!

If you're a fan of peanut butter, jelly, or the classic combo of the two, this place is a must-visit! We first discovered their Honey Roasted Peanut Butter at a farmers market and instantly fell in love. It's the perfect blend of creamy and chunky and great with anything. We had said when we bought it that we would have to make it a point to go to the store and try some of the menu. When we ran out of peanut butter it was the perfect excuse. The inside is decorated with old lunchboxes (that you can buy or trade) and has that nostalgia feel that pairs perfectly with a PB&J. The staff is incredibly friendly and patient, happily guiding you through the menu full of delicious pre-made combinations and plenty of options to customize your order. I opted for the Bagel PB, featuring Honey Roaste