Patelmo's Pizzeria

This is a perfect place to eat when you're in the East Goshen area. It's not just a pizzeria - it has great Italian food entrees. We were there Thursday evening and had the Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich (with lots of yummy eggplant) and the Angelhair Spaghetti with tasty meatballs. For dessert we had the light-as-air Tiramisu and the Fried Dough sprinkled with sugar and cinnamon. Friendly service too. Too bad it's hidden away in a minor shopping center. It's deserves better. Really!

The best pizza in the area by far. Perfect flavor and the crust was so soft yet crispy. Absolutely will return. Only point is that service was a little slow but I could tell it was because the pizza was being freshly made and baked. So amazing!!

I enjoyed this visit. Order taking was a little clunky, not sure what the holdups were…. Charismatic manager, smiling & talkative. A little in the pricey side, however the portions were decent. Mozzarella Sticks, if I was a betting man, were from the freezer but were good. Marinara, decent. The 2 specialty slices (Buffalo Chix, Pickle Bacon Ranch) were smallish. TBH not great. 1 of the areas I struggle with as a reviewer, is if an establishment has cold slices available or not. If they do & they are not good, is it fair to score it negatively against others that do not have them. IMO it would have not improved the overall score, so maybe I am putting too much thought into it. Cheeseburger Sub was HUGE!!! If I would have broken out my scale definitely well over a pound, maybe eve

One of the best pizza restaurants around. Great employees, ordering ahead for a specific time and they are on time, 6:15pm? Get there and the food is being walked out within 2 minutes of 615. Ive had a lot of cheesesteaks, theirs is one of the top 5 best ive had, from their regular to mushroom cheesesteak 9.5/10 Their pizza slices from cheese to speciality are quite delicious too.

We stopped on a whim on our way home from running errands and we're so glad we did! My daughter loved the tomato pie, and the slice she got and the chicken cheesesteak was fantastic and very generously packed with chicken, and hubby loved the burger! We've ordered several times since and are consistently impressed by the customer service staff, the quality of the food, and even their delivery service was top notch. Patelmo's has quickly become our go to pizza/sub/,sandwich/salad shop.