Papa's Pizza

Great new haven style pies out of Milford. Pick up only at the location I visited. Great tasty pies with many options cooked to perfection. I'd recommend the shrimp and bacon. 🥓

I've been a return customer for about 10 years. Unfortunately, my experience today convinced me not to return. This is a top dollar location. Today I paid the most money I've ever spent here, received the least amount of food ever and it was poorly assembled to boot. Gone are the days of a pizza that just.barely fits into the box. My large pizza was small, oddly shaped and oddly cut. The two meatball cones I ordered were served in old bread and with half the number of meatballs I've come to expect. Didn't bother calling to complain because it's over an hour round trip. I hope this is just a one off, but I won't ever come back to find out.

Went to get a barbecue chicken pizza and this is how it looks and there is no barbecue sauce or even a taste of barbecue any thing just chicken on a pizza cool won't be back

Came up from NY to try this NH style pizza. It did not disappoint. Pizza was cooked to perfection, great ingredients, and that brick oven crust 👌🏽. Very Friendly Staff!!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!

I grew up around the corner and have had their apizza since they opened in the mid eighties and I've always loved their pie. I put it on par with the more well known greats in New Haven. Definitely the best in Milford. Always great.